Now, Kansas City can enjoy delicious fried chicken and homemade pie from Rye, while gazing at the iconic JC Nichols Memorial Fountain – the modern Midwestern restaurant is scheduled to open a new location on the Country Club Plaza by Fall 2017.
Chefs Colby and Megan Garrelts announced their plans this week to open a second location for Rye in the former Morton’s Grille space. This will be the third restaurant for the award-winning chefs, after they opened their first flagship fine dining restaurant, Bluestem, in Westport in 2004, followed by Rye in Mission Farms in Leawood, KS in 2012.
Since then, Garrelts have been on a roll. After opening both of their restaurants, the national accolades for each of them and their restaurants started rolling in.
In 2013, Colby Garrelts won the James Beard Foundation Best Chef: Midwest award, followed by Bluestem receiving a 2015, 2016, and 2017 James Beard Semifinalist nod for Outstanding Restaurant in Kansas City.
Pastry Chef Megan Garrelts is also a James Beard Semifinalist for Outstanding Pastry Chef for both Bluestem and Rye. The two chefs are also the authors of two cookbooks: Bluestem, the cookbook and Made in America, and the parents of two adorable children.
With this level of national recognition, Rye on the Plaza is destined to be a real showpiece for the Garrelts’, and their culinary vision, as they will welcome both locals and tourists alike to their splashy new location. “Being able to embark on what is now our third restaurant is a direct reflection of how much the Kansas City food scene has grown,” says Colby Garrelts. “This is my hometown and having the opportunity to open Rye in a location so iconic to our city is incredible.”
This culinary couple will be joined in this venture by another one. Jeff and Joy Stehney, owners of Joe’s Kansas City Bar-B-Que, will continue to support the Garrelts’ vision for Rye both financially, as partners, and as mentors. The foursome shares a true friendship and interest in helping each other, as they continue grow their restaurant empires together in Kansas City.
The new Plaza location for Rye will have about the same amount of space that their Leawood location has -- over 7,000-square-feet. It features a large bar, while the main dining room will hold a total of 120 guests. There will be two private dining rooms that will be available to host family parties or corporate events.
Local designer, John O’Brien with Hammerout Design, who previously worked on the original Rye restaurant in Leawood, has been retained to ensure the new Plaza location will keep the same charm as the original. His goal is to create a similar feel and energy that highlights a rustic refinement that must be both comfortable enough to enjoy every day, and one that you would also want to celebrate special occasions in.
The leadership team that the Garrelts’ have strategically pulled together to man the Plaza location will pull from all of their current restaurants.
In the kitchen will be Executive Chef John Brogan who has been running the Leawood Rye kitchen for many years. The menu at Rye will continue to be a thoughtful collaboration between Colby Garrelts and Brogan that will feature signature dishes like the burnt ends and sourdough toast showcasing KC-style smoked brisket, shrimp and grits with Anson Mills cheddar grits and their famous fried chicken served with housemade pickles and ham gravy.
In the front of the house, look for General Manager Jeremy Lamb to bring his cool expertise to the new Plaza location. Having served as General Manager for both Bluestem and the Leawood location of Rye, Lamb is a trusted and familiar face that the guests look forward to seeing and the Garrelts’ have come to rely on. Known for his snappy suits, tireless wit and superior service, Lamb is the perfect person for the job.
As Lamb and Brogan leave the Leawood location, they will pass the torch to General Manager Vincent Corpuz and Executive Chef Ryan Williams, who were both recently promoted.
In the pastry kitchen, Pastry Chef Megan Garrelts will also team up with Rye’s current Pastry Chef Keara Masson, who will oversee production for both locations’ celebrated desserts. Most known for their pies, look for classic flavors and rotating seasonal options such as Lemon Meringue, Banana Cream, and Chocolate Peanut Butter Pies, in addition to traditional cakes, housemade ice cream & sorbets, and decadent ice cream sundaes.
Finally, lending his expertise to the bar at Rye on the Plaza will be Bluestem’s Bar Manager Andrew Olsen, who will oversee the beverage program. Olsen’s cocktail list incorporates timeless classics as well as the inspired twists that have made him a nationally recognized name in the beverage world.
Look for Olsen behind the main bar shaking things up or tucked inside their new private dining room, where at a fully equipped bar, he will be able to host intimate cocktail, spirits, and wine events. This private bar will also be used to host pop-up events, showcasing Olsen’s talents, making it a true insider’s cocktail destination.
Taking the opportunity with the opening of their second location for Rye, the Garrelts’ will launch their own line of BBQ and hot sauces. The Kansas City-style BBQ and smoked fresno chile hot sauces served at Rye, have finally been bottled for purchase.
Rye on The Plaza will open serving lunch and dinner only, then move to add breakfast and brunch. Eventually, Rye will serve breakfast from 8 – 11 am, lunch from 11 am – 3:30 pm, Monday – Friday. Weekend brunch Saturday & Sunday will be served from 10:30 am – 3:30 pm. Dinner will begin seven days a week starting at 4 pm.
Rye, 4646 JC Nichols Parkway, Kansas City, Missouri, facebook.com/ryekcplaza/ and ryekc.com